Superior Court Rules Table of Contents
171. (a)
Cases for Summary Jury Trial Proceedings. A judge of the Superior Court
following a Rule 62(A) pretrial settlement conference, and as part of a final
pretrial order, shall ordinarily upon written request of all counsel, and may in
other cases, order a case to be heard and decided in a summary jury trial
proceeding conducted by the Court, provided the following conditions are
satisfied:
(1) The case
is not one in which the credibility of a witness is likely to be determinative
of the outcome of the case.
(2) The
decision in the case will not set a precedent but simply requires the
application of existing law.
(3) The case
shall be in trial readiness when called for summary jury trial and all discovery
shall have been completed.
(b)
Objections To Order for Summary Jury Trial. Specific objections to an
order placing a case on the summary jury trial list shall be raised by motion
filed within ten (10) days of the mailing of notice of such order and shall be
heard by the presiding justice.
(c)
Summary Jury Trial; When and Where Held; Notice.
(1) Summary
jury trials shall be held at the time and place designated by the presiding
justice. The Court shall notify counsel in writing, at least fifteen (15) days
before the trial, of the time and place of trial.
(2) Unless
excused by order of court, clients or client representatives shall be in
attendance at the summary jury trial.
(d)
Jury Panel. The case shall be heard before a jury of six members or such
lesser number as the parties may stipulate, drawn in accordance with usual
procedures. Once a juror has served on a summary jury, he or she shall not serve
on any regular jury during the same term.
(e)
Jury Instructions. Unless excused by order of court, counsel shall submit
proposed jury instructions to the Court and opposing counsel no later than five
(5) days before the date set for hearing.
(f)
Presentation of Evidence. All evidence shall be presented through the
attorneys for the parties, who may incorporate arguments on such evidence in
their presentations. Each attorney shall be given one hour to describe to the
jury his client's view of the circumstances of the case. Counsel may reserve a
portion of the hour for a statement in rebuttal. Only evidence that would be
admissible at trial upon the merits may be presented. Counsel may only present
factual representations supportable by reference to discovery materials, to a
signed statement of a witness, to a stipulation, or to a document or by a
professional representation that counsel personally spoke with the witness and
is repeating what the witness stated. Statements, reports and depositions may be
read from, but not at undue length. Physical exhibits, including documents, may
be exhibited during a presentation and submitted for the jury's consideration.
(g)
Exhibits. Prior to the summary jury trial, counsel shall mark and
exchange copies of all proposed exhibits they plan to offer at said trial and
inform the Court whether they object to any proposed exhibit, setting forth
reasons in support thereof. Failure to exchange a proposed exhibit shall
constitute valid grounds for objection to admission. Failure to file an
objection to any exchanged proposed exhibit shall constitute a waiver of any
objection thereto.
(h)
Objections. Objections will be received if in the course of a
presentation counsel goes beyond the limits of propriety in presenting
statements as to evidence or argument thereon.
(i)
Judge's Charge. After counsel's presentations, the jury will be given an
abbreviated charge by the presiding judge on the applicable law.
(j)
Verdict. The jury may return either a consensus verdict or a special
verdict consisting of an anonymous statement of each juror's findings on
liability and/or damages (each known as the jury's advisory opinion). The jury
will be encouraged to return a consensus verdict.
(k)
Transcript. No record of the proceedings shall be permitted except in
extraordinary circumstances, as determined by the Court.
(l)
Effect of Verdict. Counsel may stipulate that a consensus verdict by the
jury will be deemed a final determination on the merits and that judgment be
entered thereon by the Court, or may stipulate to any other use of the verdict
that will aid in the resolution of the case.
(m)
Restoration to Active List; Inadmissibility of Summary Jury Trial
Proceedings. The parties shall notify the Clerk within fifteen (15) days
after entry of the summary jury trial verdict whether settlement in the case has
been reached. If a settlement agreement or stipulations for docket markings are
not filed, the case shall be forthwith restored to the trial docket. In the
event that no settlement is reached following the summary jury trial, and the
case is restored to the trial docket, no person shall be called as a witness to
testify what took place in the summary jury proceeding. In such event, the
documents relating to that proceeding and the evidence presented therein shall
be sealed and shall not be admissible, except for such evidence as is otherwise
admissible at trial under the rules of evidence. The judge who presided at the
summary jury proceeding shall not be the trial judge.