THE STATE OF NEW HAMPSHIRE

SUPREME COURT OF NEW HAMPSHIRE

O R D E R

 

Pursuant to Part II, Article 73-a of the New Hampshire Constitution and Supreme Court Rule 51(7), the Supreme Court of New Hampshire approves, as technical amendments, an amendment to Supreme Court Rule 42(5)(m) as set forth in Appendix A; repeal of Superior Court Rule 86 on a temporary basis as set forth in Appendix B; repeal of District and Municipal Court Rule 3.22 on a temporary basis as set forth in Appendix C; repeal of Probate Court Rule 86 on a temporary basis as set forth in Appendix D; and amendments to Superior Court Administrative Rule 12-9 on a temporary basis as set forth in Appendix E.

Pursuant to Part II, Article 73-a of the New Hampshire Constitution and Supreme Court Rule 51, the Supreme Court of New Hampshire approves amendments to Supreme Court Rule 12 as set forth in Appendix F.

The amendments set forth in Appendices A, B, C, D, and E shall be effective immediately. The amendments set forth in Appendix F shall be effective on March 1, 2003. The temporary amendments set forth in Appendices B, C, D and E shall be referred to the Advisory Committee on Rules for consideration of whether they should be adopted as permanent amendments.

 

January 9, 2003

                                                                ATTEST: ___________________________

                                                                              Eileen Fox, Clerk
                                                                              Supreme Court of New Hampshire

APPENDIX A

Amend Supreme Court Rule 42(5)(m) and adopt said rule on a permanent basis, so that said Rule 42(5)(m), as amended, shall state as follows:

(m) The standing committee on character and fitness shall have the power to propose regulations setting forth standards to be applied by the committee in determining whether applicants have established their moral character and fitness. Such proposed regulations shall be referred to the advisory committee on rules.

 

 

APPENDIX B

Repeal Superior Court Rule 86 on a temporary basis.

APPENDIX C

Repeal District and Municipal Court Rule 3.22 on a temporary basis.

APPENDIX D

Repeal Probate Court Rule 86 on a temporary basis.

APPENDIX E

Amend Superior Court Administrative Rule 12-9 on a temporary basis, so that said Rule 12-9, as amended, shall state as follows:

12-9. Authority of Marital Masters.

(a) Marital Masters serving in the Superior Court are authorized to hear domestic relations cases, except matters involving incarceration, as follows: divorce, child custody and visitation between unwed parties, child support, legal separation, paternity, interstate custody and child support under UIFSA, domestic violence between wed and unwed parties, and grandparent visitation.

If possible, a Marital Master presiding at the first hearing in a case will thereafter be assigned to hear all matters pertaining to that case.

(b) Marital Masters serving in the Family Division are authorized to hear family cases, except matters involving incarceration, as follows: guardianship over minors, abuse and neglect of children, divorce, child custody and visitation between unwed parties, child support, legal separation, paternity, interstate custody and child support under UIFSA, domestic violence between wed and unwed parties, and grandparent visitation.

If possible, a Marital Master presiding at the first hearing in a case will thereafter be assigned to hear all matters pertaining to that case.

APPENDIX F

Amend Supreme Court Rule 12(1)(c) and adopt Rule 12, as amended, on a permanent basis, so that said Rule 12, as amended, shall state as follows:

 

 

RULE 12. REQUESTS FOR CONFIDENTIALITY OF CASE RECORDS; ACCESS TO CASE RECORDS

(1) Supreme Court Records Subject to Public Inspection.

(a) General Rule. In all cases in which relief is sought in the supreme court, all pleadings, docketed entries, and filings related thereto (hereinafter referred to as "case records") shall be available for public inspection unless otherwise ordered by the court in accordance with this rule.

(b) Exceptions. The following categories of case records are not available for public inspection:

(1) records of juvenile cases, including cases of delinquency, abuse or neglect, children in need of services, termination of parental rights, and adoption, which by statute are confidential;

(2) applications for a grand jury and grand jury records, which by statute and common law are confidential;

(3) records of other cases that are confidential by statute, administrative or court rule, or court order.

(c) Burden of Proof. The burden of proving that a case record or a portion of a case record should be confidential rests with the party or person seeking confidentiality.

(2) Procedure For Requesting Confidentiality of a Case Record or a Portion of a Case Record in a Supreme Court Case.

(a) Case Record or Portion of Case Record That Has Already Been Determined to be Confidential. The following procedure shall be followed when the case record or a portion of the case record was determined to be confidential by the trial court, administrative agency, or other tribunal:

(1) The appealing party shall indicate on the notice of appeal form or in the appeal document, e.g., appeal from administrative agency, that the case record or a portion of the case record was determined to be confidential by the trial court, administrative agency, or other tribunal, and shall cite the authority for confidentiality, e.g., the statute, administrative or court rule, or court order providing for confidentiality. Upon filing, the portion of the case record determined to be confidential by the trial court, administrative agency, or other tribunal shall remain confidential pending review by the supreme court.

(2) Within 30 days of the appeal being filed with the supreme court, a single justice of the supreme court shall review the case record or the portion of the case record determined to be confidential by the trial court, administrative agency, or other tribunal, and shall decide whether the case record or portion of the record in question shall remain confidential in the supreme court. The justice may refer the question to the full court for a ruling.

(3) Based on the review of the single justice or the court, an order will be issued which indicates whether the case record or a portion of the case record is confidential.

(b) Cases in Which There Has Been No Prior Determination of Confidentiality. The following procedure shall be followed when a party or other person with standing seeks to have the case record or a portion of the case record determined to be confidential by the supreme court:

(1) Any party or other person with standing who seeks a determination that a case record or a portion of a case record is confidential shall file a motion to seal the case record or the portion of the case record in question. The motion shall state the authority for confidentiality, i.e., the statute, administrative or court rule providing for confidentiality, or the privacy interest or circumstance that requires confidentiality. Upon filing of the motion to seal, the case record or the portion of the case record which is the subject of the motion shall be kept confidential pending a ruling on the motion.

(2) Within 30 days of filing, a motion to seal will be reviewed by a single justice of the court who shall determine whether the case record or the portion of the case record that is the subject of the motion shall be confidential or who may refer the motion to the full court for a ruling.

(3) An order will be issued setting forth the ruling on the motion to seal.

(c) Court Action When Confidentiality is Required.

(1) The failure of a party or other person with standing to request that a case record or a portion of a case record be confidential shall not preclude the court from determining on its own motion that a statute, administrative or court rule, or other compelling interest requires that a case record or a portion of a case record proceeding be kept confidential.

(2) Before sealing a case record or a portion of a case record, a single justice or the court must determine that there is a basis for keeping the case record confidential.

(3) If a single justice or the court determines that a case record or a portion of a case record should be confidential, an order will be issued setting forth the ruling.

(d) Access to Supreme Court Orders On Confidentiality.

Every order of the supreme court that a case record or a portion of a case record is confidential shall be available for public inspection. Information which would compromise the court's determination of confidentiality, e.g., the name of a juvenile, shall be redacted.

(3) Procedure For Seeking Access To Case Records That Have Been Determined to be Confidential.

(a) A person who is neither a party nor counsel in a case and who seeks access to a case record or portion of a case record that has been determined by the supreme court to be confidential shall file a petition with the court requesting access to the record in question.

(b) Upon receipt of the petition, an order of notice shall be issued to all parties and other persons with standing in the case.

(c) A single justice of the supreme court or a judicial referee appointed by the court shall examine the case record in question to determine whether there is a basis for nondisclosure.

(d) An order shall be issued setting forth the justice's or referee's ruling on the petition, which shall be made public. In the event that the justice or referee determines that the records are confidential, the order shall include findings of fact and rulings of law that support the decision of nondisclosure.

(e) Within 10 days of the date of the clerk's notice of the justice's or referee's decision, any party or person with standing aggrieved by the decision may file a motion for review by the full court.